Morgan Mystery – Where was Morgan Mansion/Manor?

- 1940 Aerial Map of the Tyler Street, Robinson Place, Dodd Place and Willow Street Block North of Route 35 in Morgan, NJ courtesy of HistoricAerials.com – Click on the HistoricAerials.com Image Below to allow for Interactive Panning, Zooming and Changing Years.
I can’t say that it is an obsession but it could easily become one. It is certainly a mystery and I, on occasion, wonder if it will always be a mystery or whether someone will someday provide documented proof of where the Morgan Family mansion/manor used to be physically located. By the time I came into the picture as a child, there were no remains of it left in Morgan.
The Morgan family settled in present day Morgan-NJ, depending on who/what you believe, sometime in the late 1600’s or early 1700’s. The only documented information I have encountered to date on this subject is contained in two sources. The first documented source is from a map contained in the Huntington Library in San Marino, CA (near Pasadena). Incidentally, the Huntington Library and Botanical Gardens is a beautiful place to visit. If you are ever in the Southern California area, do plan to spend most of a day there. The map is designated as “H M 530” and is entitled “Boundaries of Central N. J. Patents 1681 – 1776 Between the South & Raritan Rivers”. Thanks to Ms. Alvia Disbrow Martin, everyone has easy access to a traced copy of this map in her fantastic book “At the Headwaters of Cheesequake Creek” (available from The Thomas Warne Museum & Library of The Madison Township Historical Society in Old Bridge Township, NJ). The write-up for tract #62 on the map shows the land transferred from “Philip Carteret 1681… To Townley Sir. Townley (sic) to Everson (illegible) to Morgan?” Philip Carteret was the 1st and 4th British Colonial Governor of East Jersey and cousin of Sir George Carteret, the original Proprietor of East Jersey (more about East/West Jersey and Proprietors in future postings). Tract #62 is bordered on the east by Raritan Bay and on the south by Cheesequake Creek. It very closely resembles what is now considered to be Morgan-NJ (see the posting from 22 August 2009).
The second documented source is page 339 from a land record index known as the “Colonial Conveyances in the Providence of New Jersey, 1664-1794″ which was provided to me by my school friend, Joe. On this page are the following two entries:
- 27 May 1710 – a tract of land “On S/si of Raritan River” from Richard Townley to Charles Morgan.
- 26 August 1730 – a tract of land “near Cheesequake, Middlesex” from George Leslie to Charles Morgan.
While the above is all well and good, it still doesn’t answer the question. Thus far the closest documented description of the location of the mansion/manor is contained in the 1932 book “This Old Monmouth of Ours” by William S. Hornor. This book is composed of reprints of articles from the defunct newspaper The Freehold Transcript which means the information is even older. One portion of it discusses the location of the mansion of the Morgan Family:
“Captain James Morgan, (the wealthy General Morgan of Revolutionary times) [VJ: they are confusing Captain James Morgan, Sr. and Major General James Morgan, Jr.], lived on the high bluff immediately north of the mouth of Cheesequake Creek, where the fire-blackened ruins of his mansion and the noble lines of trees marking the long avenue of approach to it could still be seen but a few years ago. The Morgan burying ground is about a quarter of a mile away, and there are to be seen the tombs of General Morgan and of many of his family.”
The only other tidbits of information I have presently on this subject are from two sources. My first source, Sue, was one year ahead of me at Jesse Selover through Sayreville War Memorial High School. She has amazed me with the amount of Morgan research she has performed and material she has accumulated. It has been a real pleasure reconnecting with her and learning from each other. Incidentally her father is a master model builder and is presently at work on a model of the Old Spye Inn so if you have any photos, diagrams, etc. of the Old Spye Inn, please forward them to me so I can forward them to her (or post a comment below so I can contact you). Her research indicated that the Morgan mansion burned in 1865. This sounds plausible especially if one takes into consideration that James Rutus Morgan was a Confederate sympathizer who reportedly was friends with Confederate General Robert E. Lee and was said to have provided supplies such as gun powder to the Southern cause. Note that the Civil War ended in 1865 the same year Sue indicated the mansion burned down. James Rutus Morgan named his son Robert E. Lee Morgan. Robert E. Lee Morgan is the person that sold Henry Luhrs the property on Cheesequake Creek where Henry started his famous boat businesses (see posting from 10 January 2010) and probably was the inspiration for the owners of the Robert E. Lee Inn to name it such.
The final piece of information I have comes from Ed, my Morgan family contact who wrote to me, “The original family home was where Lockwoods Marina is today. It was about twenty feet higher than it is today. The Lockwoods had the hill leveled.”
Ed’s information matches the description from “This Old Monmouth of Ours” in that Lockwood’s is about a quarter of a mile away from the “Morgan burying grounds” as the sea gull flys. However, does this location match “high bluff immediately north of the mouth of Cheesequake Creek”? That description more aptly matches what is now the south most portion of Morgan Ave or Cliff Avenue, the portion south of Route 35. This location seems much more plausible if you take into account what the mouth of Cheesequake Creek looked like during the time period of James Morgan, Sr. and James Morgan, Jr. (see posting from 19 September 2010). However, the southernmost part of Morgan Avenue is also closer to the “Morgan burying grounds” than a quarter mile.
Click on this image to go interactive!
The final enigma relates to “the noble lines of trees marking the long avenue of approach to the fire-blackened ruins of his mansion”. If you look at the 1940 photo from one of my all time favorite web sites, HistoricAerials.com, you will see rows of mature trees lining what are now named Tyler Street, Robinson Place, Dodd Place, Willow Street and even a little of Morgan Avenue. None if any of these trees remain today. If they were so mature in 1940 as to be easily seen in an aerial photograph, they would surely have had to have been planted at least 100 years prior – or more. Also take into account that present day Tyler Street was, according to the 1919 Sanborn Map of Morgan (see posting from 2 January 2010), named Main Street. Before Route 35 was built in the 1920s, Main Street ran all the way down to Cheesequake Creek to the site of the Old Spye Inn. Is it possible that these were “the noble lines of trees marking the long avenue of approach”?
Many thanks to Joe, Ed & Sue for contributing information for this posting. I hope to have more information in the near future regarding the early land holdings of the Morgan family and how they relate to present day Morgan. In the mean time, if you have any information or insight about the mansion, PLEASE post a comment below.
